Our Story Rooms Experience Location Guests Contact Reserve Now
Key West Boutique Lodging

What if your Key West stay felt less like a hotel — and more like a sanctuary?

Tucked along a quiet lane in the heart of the island, Passover Cottage offers an intimate retreat where classic elegance meets the easy rhythm of the Keys. Four thoughtfully appointed rooms, a courtyard that breathes, and the warmth of a home that has welcomed travelers for decades.

Explore Our Rooms (847) 267-0192
37+ Years Hosting
4 Boutique Rooms
4.9 Guest Rating
Passover Cottage exterior with tropical landscaping in Key West Courtyard seating area with lush tropical plants
Key West Florida
Elegant interior of Passover Cottage with classic furnishings Sun-dappled courtyard at Passover Cottage
Our Story

A Key West tradition
crafted with care

Passover Cottage was born from a simple conviction: the best places to stay are the ones that feel like they were made with genuine intention — not assembled from a checklist. Nestled on a tree-lined street just minutes from Duval Avenue, our cottage has been a quiet refuge for discerning travelers since 1987.

Each of our four rooms is individually designed, drawing on the rich architectural heritage of Key West — from original heart-pine floors and hand-carved moldings to curated artwork and linens chosen for their substance. We believe hospitality is found in the details: the weight of a well-made towel, the angle of morning light across a courtyard table, the difference between being lodged and being welcomed.

Historic Character — Original 1930s architecture preserved with modern comfort
Intimate Scale — Only four rooms ensures personalized attention
Quiet Location — A serene lane, steps from everything
Curated Experience — Hand-selected amenities and local insights
Accommodations

Four rooms, each with its own story

Every space at Passover Cottage has been thoughtfully designed to balance the elegance of Key West's architectural past with the comfort of contemporary living.

The Conch Room with king bed and coastal artwork King

The Conch Room

Our signature suite, named for the island's iconic shell architecture. Features a king bed dressed in Egyptian cotton, a private balcony overlooking the courtyard, and original plaster walls that date to the cottage's founding.

King Bed Balcony Rain Shower Smart TV
Inquire
The Marlin Room with queen bed and ocean accents Queen

The Marlin Room

A refined retreat for the solitary traveler or couple. The Marlin Room offers a queen bed, a work desk crafted from reclaimed teak, and a deep soaking tub — perfect for unwinding after a day on the water.

Queen Bed Soaking Tub Work Desk Smart TV
Inquire
The Palmetto Room with two double beds and tropical views Two Doubles

The Palmetto Room

Designed for families or friends traveling together, the Palmetto Room features two comfortable double beds, a generous seating area, and a window that frames the swaying fronds of a century-old palmetto.

2 Double Beds Seating Area Garden View Smart TV
Inquire
The Experience

What makes a stay
at Passover Cottage different

We don't do chain-hotel standardization. What we offer is something rarer — a place that has been considered, curated, and cared for, room by room.

Courtyard Garden

A shaded, plant-filled courtyard with comfortable seating — the perfect spot for morning coffee or an evening drink beneath the string lights.

Concierge Service

From restaurant reservations to private charters, our team provides personalized recommendations and arrangements tailored to your interests.

Historic Charm

Heart-pine floors, hand-carved details, and original architectural elements preserved with care — every corner tells a story.

Island Location

A quiet residential street, yet only minutes from the beach, Duval Avenue, and the best seafood restaurants Key West has to offer.

Location

In the heart of Key West,
removed from the noise

728 Passover Lane sits on one of the island's most pleasant residential streets — tree-lined, quiet, and authentically Key West. You'll wake to the sound of birds rather than traffic, yet find yourself at the beach, the wharf, and the vibrant restaurant scene in just a few minutes.

2-minute walk to the beach
5 minutes to Duval Avenue
10 minutes to Mallory Square
Free on-site parking
Colorful historic architecture and palm trees along a Key West street
728 Passover Ln
Key West, FL 33040
Guest Experiences

What our guests say

The compliments we receive most often aren't about amenities — they're about the feeling a stay here leaves behind.

"

We've stayed at resorts across the Keys, but nothing compares to the warmth and refinement we found here. The Conch Room was absolutely stunning — the kind of place that makes you want to stay longer than you planned.

Guest photo
Margaret & James
Atlanta, Georgia
"

The location is perfect — quiet enough to sleep deeply, close enough to walk everywhere. The courtyard is a dream, and the staff remembered our names from day one. This is what a boutique inn should be.

Guest photo
David K.
Chicago, Illinois
"

We celebrated our anniversary here and the attention to detail was remarkable. The concierge arranged a private sunset sail, and the room was decorated beautifully. Truly a once-in-a-lifetime experience.

Guest photo
Sarah & Robert
New York, New York
Begin Your Stay

Your Key West sanctuary
is waiting

Whether you're planning a romantic escape, a family reunion, or a quiet week to recharge — Passover Cottage is ready to welcome you. Reach out to discuss your ideal dates and we'll make sure every detail is considered.

Request Reservations Call Us
(847) 267-0192
Get in Touch

We'd love to
hear from you

Have a question about availability, special requests, or planning a group stay? Reach out — we respond personally, usually within a few hours.

Address
728 Passover Ln
Key West, FL 33040-7104
Check-in / Check-out
Check-in: 3:00 PM — Check-out: 11:00 AM

Send Us a Message

Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you shortly.

Message Sent

Thank you for reaching out. We'll respond within a few hours — usually sooner.

Is this your business? Claim your website
Your own domain includedLive in minutes, edit anytime
Claim my website